Oatmeal Creme Pie Cookie Cake Recipe

Warm, spiced, nostalgic and impossible to resist. 🤎

This Oatmeal Creme Pie Cookie Cake starts with a soft cinnamon oatmeal cookie cake base, gets finished with our classic vanilla buttercream, and topped with a golden brown sugar crumble — a bakery-style take on the childhood classic that feels familiar and a little fancy all at once.

It's got warmth from the cinnamon, chew from the oats, and that creamy vanilla finish that makes every bite feel complete.

THIS DIGITAL RECIPE DOWNLOAD INCLUDES

✨ Step-by-step instructions for the cookie cake, vanilla buttercream + brown sugar crumble

✨ Ingredient measurements in cups and grams

✨ Clear yields, portion sizes + scoop sizes

✨ Bake It 4 Ways instructions for:

• Mini Cookie Cakes
• Boxed Cookie Cakes
• Cookie Cake Bites
• Cookie Cupcakes

✨ The Cookie Cake Breakdown with the pans, scoops + packaging I use

✨ Ingredient-specific notes for oats, cinnamon + brown sugar crumble topping

✨ Storage, freezing, make-ahead + serving guidance

✨ Real-life troubleshooting

✨ Gluten-free 1:1 substitution guidance

✨ Supply guidance featuring the tools and packaging I personally use

BAKE IT 4 WAYS

One recipe can become four different products:

1️⃣ Mini Cookie Cakes
2️⃣ Boxed Cookie Cakes
3️⃣ Cookie Cake Bites
4️⃣ Cookie Cupcakes

Perfect for weekly menus, markets, custom orders, treat boxes and special occasions.

FLAVOUR DETAILS

The cookie cake is made with:

🤎 A cinnamon oatmeal cookie cake base — chewy, spiced and soft-baked with that classic oatmeal cookie warmth

🤍 Classic vanilla buttercream for a smooth, creamy finish that lets the oatmeal flavour shine

🤎 Brown sugar crumble topping for golden, caramelized texture in every bite

PERFECT FOR

🍪 Home bakery menus

🍪 Markets + pop-ups

🍪 Fall and cozy-season collections

🍪 Comfort-flavour dessert boxes

🍪 Oatmeal cookie lovers

🍪 Anyone looking to add a nostalgic, crowd-favourite flavour to their menu

DIGITAL DOWNLOAD

This is a digital recipe PDF. No physical product will be shipped. Your recipe will be available electronically after purchase.

Please note: This recipe may be used by the purchaser for personal baking or to create finished baked goods for sale. The recipe file itself may not be copied, shared, distributed, reproduced or resold in any format. Due to the nature of digital downloads, all sales are final and non-refundable.